The pseudonym "Philo Vaihinger" has been abandoned. All posts have been and are written by me, Joseph Auclair.

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Russian Afghanistan



They were doing good work there.

We should have helped them and not the Islamists.

The Iranian Revolution should have taught us all we needed to know about Islamic fundamentalism.

Even then, the Islamists were an added threat in regions of the world where the Russians were not or were already in check.

Sure, it was nice that they bled each other for us.

But it would have made more sense to let the Russians have their way in Afghanistan, so long as they didn’t actually put much of a permanent occupying force there, than to let crackpot Islamism get another country to control, all by itself.

Why didn’t Reagan and his gang see it that way, though like everyone else they had just lived through the long agony of the hostage crisis?

My guesses.

First, a grotesque underestimation of the long-term threat of Islamism – a threat many of Reagan’s people would go on to wildly exaggerate post 9/11.

And second, as Jimmy Carter once put it, an “inordinate fear of communism” in Europe where we stood toe-to-toe unnecessarily (Europe could have handled it) with the Warsaw Pact.

Recall that the primary reason for the American role in the Cold War and the vacillation of the American ruling class between policies of stupid containment and stupider rollback was that they felt both mortal terror of and moral hate for both the planned economy and the utopian delusions of Marxism, for which Soviet Russia at the time still stood.

Of course, another is that they did not want Europe to emerge as an independent super-power capable of facing off the Soviets all by itself.

We are currently a world with one super-power, and that is the way our ruling class likes things.

Why is China OK today - though maybe not so OK tomorrow?

Not a super-power (yet), not in Europe, and no Far Eastern version of the Warsaw Pact exists (yet).

But perhaps most important of all, China is not a global advertisement for or champion of an economic full-scale alternative to capitalism.

And is not really likely to become one, so far as one can foresee that sort of thing.

No comments:

Post a Comment